Discover a new way to order.
Try our new mobile app today!
Open
×
×
Try Our New Mobile App!
Find out what we’ve been up to.
Open
place
Search for restaurants nearby...
For Restaurant Owners
Sign In
Pickup
Delivery
Search
×
Download the Beyond Menu App
Get the Beyond Menu app to make ordering from your local spot easier than ever.
error
Custodi Caterers
551 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110
Delivery Info
Delivery Fee
$5 within 3.00 miles
Delivery Minimum
$150.00
Estimated Time
Between 30 and 60 minutes
Not accepting online orders
View other restaurants nearby »
Delivery Fee
$5.00
Delivery Minimum
$150.00
Menu
Info & Hours
Delivery Fee
$5 within 3.00 miles
Delivery Minimum
$150.00
Estimated Time
Between 30 and 60 minutes
×
Download the Beyond Menu App
Get the Beyond Menu app to make ordering from your local spot easier than ever.
Menu
Ala Carte Specials - Sandwich Platters
Ala Carte Specials - Submarine Sandwiches
Ala Carte Specials - Individual Platters
Ala Carte Specials - Fresh Cold Salads
Ala Carte Specials - Fresh Fruits
Specialty Salads (New!)
Stuffed Breads
Specialty Sandwiches
Individual Hot Trays - Pasta
Individual Hot Trays - Rice And Beans
Individual Hot Trays - Potatoes
Individual Hot Trays - Vegetables
Individual Hot Trays - Poultry
Individual Hot Trays - Beef
Individual Hot Trays - Pork
Individual Hot Trays - Seafood
Individual Hot Trays - Veal
Individual Hot Trays - Hors D'oeuvers
Desserts
Specialty Desserts
clear
No Results Found
Your search entry does not match any items under this menu.
Please try searching for a different item or under a different menu.
Clear Search
Ala Carte Specials - Sandwich Platters
Ala Carte Specials - Submarine Sandwiches
Ala Carte Specials - Individual Platters
Ala Carte Specials - Fresh Cold Salads
Ala Carte Specials - Fresh Fruits
Specialty Salads (New!)
Stuffed Breads
Specialty Sandwiches
Individual Hot Trays - Pasta
Individual Hot Trays - Rice And Beans
Individual Hot Trays - Potatoes
Individual Hot Trays - Vegetables
Individual Hot Trays - Poultry
Individual Hot Trays - Beef
Individual Hot Trays - Pork
Individual Hot Trays - Seafood
Individual Hot Trays - Veal
Individual Hot Trays - Hors D'oeuvers
Desserts
Specialty Desserts
Ala Carte Specials - Sandwich Platters
list
Create your own sandwich platter; choice of rye, white or wheat breads, or Kaiser roll. Croissant Sandwiches - add .35 additional
Ham Sandwich
$5.50
Ham Wrap
$6.00
Ham Sloppy Joe
$5.75
American Cheese Sandwich
$5.50
American Cheese Wrap
$6.00
American Cheese Sloppy Joe
$5.75
Turkey Sandwich
$5.50
Turkey Wrap
$6.00
Turkey Sloppy Joe
$5.75
Provolone Sandwich
$5.50
Provolone Wrap
$6.00
Provolone Sloppy Joe
$5.75
Corned Beef Sandwich
$5.50
Corned Beef Wrap
$6.00
Corned Beef Sloppy Joe
$5.75
Swiss Cheese Sandwich
$5.50
Swiss Cheese Wrap
$6.00
Swiss Cheese Sloppy Joe
$5.75
Roast Beef Sandwich
$5.50
Roast Beef Wrap
$6.00
Roast Beef Sloppy Joe
$5.75
Shrimp Salad Sandwich
$5.50
Shrimp Salad Wrap
$6.00
Shrimp Salad Sloppy Joe
$5.75
Salami Sandwich
$5.50
Salami Wrap
$6.00
Salami Sloppy Joe
$5.75
Tuna Salad Sandwich
$5.50
Tuna Salad Wrap
$6.00
Tuna Salad Sloppy Joe
$5.75
Egg Salad Sandwich
$5.50
Egg Salad Wrap
$6.00
Egg Salad Sloppy Joe
$5.75
Chicken Salad Sandwich
$5.50
Chicken Salad Wrap
$6.00
Chicken Salad Sloppy Joe
$5.75
Sloppy Joes
$5.75
Roasted Vegetables Sandwich
$5.50
Roasted Vegetables Wrap
$6.00
Roasted Vegetables Sloppy Joe
$5.75
Chicken Caesar Wrap
$6.00
Ala Carte Specials - Submarine Sandwiches
list
3 Foot Sub (10-15 people)
$41.95
4 Foot Sub (15-20 people)
$51.95
5 Foot Sub (20-30 people)
$61.95
6 Foot Sub (30-40 people)
$71.95
Ala Carte Specials - Individual Platters
list
Cold Antipasto
$60.00+
Premium Antipasto
$80.00+
Cold Cut Platter
$45.00+
Assorted Cheese and Pepperoni
$55.00+
Fresh Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers
$55.00+
Shrimp Cocktail
$85.00+
Italian Cold Cut Platter
$65.00+
Vegetable Crudite with Dill Dip
$55.00+
Condiment Platter, lettuce, tomato, pickle
$45.00+
Ala Carte Specials - Fresh Cold Salads
list
Tossed Green Salad 1
$25.00+
Classic Caesar Salad
$35.00+
Broccoli Salad
$40.00+
Seafood Salad
$75.00+
Red Potato Salad
$35.00+
Cole Slaw
$30.00+
Tomato & Onion with fresh mozzarella
$35.00+
Tossed Green Salad 2
$20.00+
Mescucuin Salad
$30.00+
Mixed Baby Greens with mandarin oranges & walnuts
$40.00+
Pasta Salad
$35.00+
Caesar Salad
$35.00+
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
$45.00+
Italian Style Potato Salad
$40.00+
String Bean Salad
$40.00+
Creamy Macaroni
$40.00+
German Potato Salad - NEW!
$35.00+
Couscous Salad - NEW!
$35.00+
Warm Pasta Salad - NEW!
$35.00+
Ala Carte Specials - Fresh Fruits
list
Fruit Platters
$50.00+
Fruit Salad (in bowls)
$40.00+
Specialty Salads (New!)
list
All salads come with dressing on the side and any of the following dressings may be substituted for any salad: Balsamic, Vinaigrette, Caesar, Russian, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Green Goddess, Oil & Vinegar. To include grilled chickem, add $6.00 for medium size and $8.00 for large.
Chef Salad
Crisp Iceberg and Romaine lettuce, red cabbage, grated carrots, red onion, tomatoes, ham, turkey, and provolone
$40.00+
Mixed Baby Greens Salad
A flavorful blend of greens with Mandarin orange slices and walnuts
$40.00+
Cranberry Salad
Mixed baby greens with dried cranberries, crumbled goat cheese and walnuts in a Balsamic vinaigrette dressing
$40.00+
Spinach Salad
Baby spinach, eggs, walnuts, fresh mushrooms, and red onions in a honey Vinaigrette dressing
$40.00+
Apple Salad
Mixed baby greens garnished with apple, crumbled goat cheese, and carmelized walnuts with a raspberry Vinaigrette dressing
$40.00+
Greek Salad
Romaine lettuce, green pepper, red onion, cherry tomatoes, cucumber slices, feta cheese, and Kalamata olives in a lemon garlic Vinaigrette
$40.00+
Vegetable Salad
Mixed baby greens with cucumbers, cauliflower, broccoli, carrots, tomatoes, and asparagus sprouts with a Green Goddess dressing.
$45.00+
Mediterranean Pasta Salad
A favorite palate pleaser with blended feta cheese, tomatoes, artichoke hearts, and cavatelli pasta with a summery olive oil, lemon, and garlic dressing
$45.00+
Stuffed Breads
list
Sausage & Mozzarella Stuffed Bread
$16.00
Pepperoni & Mozzarella Stuffed Bread
$16.00
Cheese Steak Stuffed Bread
$18.00
Grilled Chicken, Roasted Peppers & Mozzarella Stuffed Bread
$20.00
Broccoli & Cheddar Stuffed Bread
$16.00
Sausage, Broccoli Rabe & Mozzarella Stuffed Bread
$18.00
Specialty Sandwiches
list
Breaded Chicken Cutlet with Broccoli Rabe & Homemade Fresh Mozzarella
$8.00+
Grilled Chicken Cutlet with Broccoli Rabe & Homemade Fresh Mozzarella
$8.00+
Grilled Chicken Cutlet with Pepperjack Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, and Russian Dressing
$7.00+
Grilled Chicken Cutlet with Roasted Red Peppers, Homemade Fresh Mozzarella, and Balsamic Vinegar
$9.50+
Grilled Chicken Cutlet with Crist Romaine Lettuce and our Homemade Creamy Caesar Dressing
$6.00+
Roasted Vegetables with Homemade Fresh Mozzarella and Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing
$5.75+
Prosciutto Di Parma with Roasted Red Peppers, Homemade Fresh Mozzarella, and Sun Dried Tomatoes
$15.00+
Mortadella, Hot or Sweet Cappacola, Gennoa Salami, Provolone, with Lettuce, Tomato, Salt, Pepper, and Oregano
$8.50+
Fresh Roasted Breast of Turkey with Provolone, Mixed Greens, and Cranberry Relish
$6.00+
Roast Beef, Provolone, Roasted Peppers, Red Onions, with Mango Hashnero or Horseradish Mustard Sauce
$8.50+
Individual Hot Trays - Pasta
list
All trays include chafing dishes and serving spoons. Our hot tray list has been updated with new items!
Lasagna
$40.00+
Lasagna with Meat
$45.00+
Vegetable Lasagna
$45.00+
Baked Ziti
$30.00+
Manicotti
$40.00+
Cavatelli & Broccoli
$37.00+
Macaroni & Cheese
$30.00+
Stuffed Shells
$40.00+
Tortellini Carbonara
$37.00+
Baked Cavatelli
$30.00+
Tortellini Alfredo
$37.00+
Ravioli with meat sauce
$37.00+
Baked Rigatonni
$30.00+
Stuffed Rigatoni (in basil cream)
$37.00+
Tortellini with crab sauce
$40.00+
Pasta Vodka
$40.00+
Cavatelli & Broccoli w/ boneless chicken breast
$42.00+
Cavatelli & Broccoli w/ sliced sausage
$42.00+
Rigatoni with meat sauce
$35.00+
Pasta Primavera
$40.00+
Linguine with white or red clam sauce
$45.00+
Gnocchi Bolognese
$37.00+
Fried Ravioli
$40.00+
Noodle Pudding
$37.00+
Pierogies
$40.00+
Individual Hot Trays - Rice And Beans
list
All trays include chafing dishes and serving spoons. Our hot tray list has been updated with new items!
Rice Pilaf
$30.00+
Brown Rice
$25.00+
Spanish Rice & Chicken
$37.00+
Spanish Rice & Beans
$35.00+
Homemade Baked Beans
$45.00+
Cajun Rice with Beef
$37.00+
Coconut Rice
$30.00+
Individual Hot Trays - Potatoes
list
All trays include chafing dishes and serving spoons. Our hot tray list has been updated with new items!
Italian Roasted Potatoes
$30.00+
Mashed Potatoes
$35.00+
Mashed Sweet Potatoes
$35.00+
Roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes
$40.00+
Candied Sweet Potatoes
$35.00+
Rosemary Roasted Red Potatoes
$30.00+
French Fries
$25.00+
Garlic Parmesan Fries
$35.00+
Individual Hot Trays - Vegetables
list
All trays include chafing dishes and serving spoons. Our hot tray list has been updated with new items!
Eggplant Parmigiana
$35.00+
Eggplant Rollatine
$40.00+
Broccoli Rabe Saute
$37.00+
Broccoli Rabe with Sausage
$42.00+
Fresh Broccoli Saute
$30.00+
String Beans Saute
$40.00+
String Bean Almondine
$45.00+
String Bean Oregenata
$40.00+
Glazed Carrots
$40.00+
Fresh Steamed Vegetables
$35.00+
Asparagus Saute
$45.00+
Corn
$15.00+
Collard Greens
$40.00+
Red Cabbage with Apple
$35.00+
Braised Stuffed Peppers
$35.00+
Stuffed Cabbage
$40.00+
Individual Hot Trays - Poultry
list
All trays include chafing dishes and serving spoons. Our hot tray list has been updated with new items!
Chicken Francese
$42.00+
Chicken Picatta
$42.00+
Chicken Giambotta
$42.00+
Chicken Rollatine
$55.00+
Chicken Fingers
$40.00+
Buffalo Wings (hot or medium)
$35.00+
Garlic Buffalo Wings
$35.00+
BBQ Wings
$35.00+
Baked Chicken
$37.00+
Chicken Capri
full trays only
$80.00
Chicken Sorrentino
full trays only
$80.00
Chicken Murphy (on the bone)
$37.00+
Chicken Murphy (boneless)
$42.00+
Chicken Savoy (on the bone)
$37.00+
Chicken Marsala
$42.00+
Chicken Cacciatore
$42.00+
Chicken Parmigiana
$42.00+
Chicken Joseph
$45.00+
Chicken Cordon Bleu
$60.00+
Chicken Stir Fry
$40.00+
Hot Turkey Breast with Gravy
$45.00+
Fried Chicken
$40.00+
Bourbon Chicken over Rice
$45.00+
Dark Beef Marinated BBQ Chicken
$42.00+
Chicken Breast w/ Sun Dried Tomato Cream Sauce
$42.00+
Individual Hot Trays - Beef
list
All trays include chafing dishes and serving spoons. Our hot tray list has been updated with new items!
Filet Mignon
Prices vary according to market.
$0.00+
Pepper Steak over Rice
$55.00+
Italian Style Hot Dogs
$35.00+
Meatballs (plain or parmigiana)
$40.00+
Meatloaf
$40.00+
Swedish Meatballs
$40.00+
Sweet and Sour Meatballs
$40.00+
Beef Stir Fry
$55.00+
Texas Style Beef Brisket
$55.00+
Roast Beef w/ Gravy
$45.00+
Individual Hot Trays - Pork
list
All trays include chafing dishes and serving spoons. Our hot tray list has been updated with new items!
Sliced Pork Loin w/ tangy sherry wine sauce
$45.00+
Spiral Ham
Prices vary according to market.
$0.00+
Sliced Ham w/ Maple & Brown Sugar Glaze
$45.00+
Sausage & Peppers (hot or sweet)
$40.00+
Sausage & Giambotta (hot or sweet)
$40.00+
Kielbasa & Sauerkraut
$45.00+
BBQ Spare Ribs
$55.00+
Pork Cutlet Murphy
$45.00+
Pork Cutlet Marsala
$45.00+
Pork Cutlet Giambotta
$45.00+
BBQ Pulled Pork
$45.00+
Ribs w/ Coconut Rum Glaze
$55.00+
Jagerschnitzel
$50.00+
Garlic Cajun Ribs
$55.00+
Kalua Pig
$45.00+
Cajun Pulled Pork w/ Mojo Sauce
$45.00+
Individual Hot Trays - Seafood
list
All trays include chafing dishes and serving spoons. Our hot tray list has been updated with new items!
Zuppa Di Clams (over linguine - red)
$45.00+
Lobster Ravioli (with shrimp or crab sauce)
$75.00+
Shrimp & Broccoli Rabe (over linguine)
$75.00+
Shrimp Scampi
$65.00+
Stuffed Shrimp
$80.00+
Broiled Filet
$50.00+
Shrimp & Scallop Scampi
$70.00+
Shrimp & Scallop Fradiavlo
$70.00+
Shrimp Fradiavlo
$70.00+
Shrimp & Garlic Sauce
$65.00+
Fried Shrimp
$70.00+
Fried Flounder
$60.00+
Fried Mixed Seafood
$75.00+
Poached Salmon
$75.00+
Seafood Paella
$75.00+
Maple Glazed Salmon w/ Pineapple Salsa
$75.00+
Creole Rubbed Salmon w/ Pineapple, Mango, Strawberry Salsa
$75.00+
Individual Hot Trays - Veal
list
All trays include chafing dishes and serving spoons. Our hot tray list has been updated with new items!
Veal & Peppers
$45.00+
Veal Murphy
$65.00+
Veal Picatta
$65.00+
Veal Rollatine
$70.00+
Veal Marsala
$65.00+
Veal Joseph
$75.00+
Individual Hot Trays - Hors D'oeuvers
list
All trays include chafing dishes and serving spoons. Our hot tray list has been updated with new items!
Stuffed Mushrooms Vegetarian
$37.00+
Stuffed Mushrooms with crab meat
$42.00+
Mussels (hot or sweet)
$40.00+
Cocktail Franks
$35.00+
Pizza Bagels
$30.00+
Cheese Puffs
$45.00+
Crab Cakes
$60.00+
Clams Oreganato
$45.00+
Clams Casino with bacon
$45.00+
Scallops & Bacon
$75.00+
Coconut Shrimp
$70.00+
Bacon Wrapped Sirloin Gorgonzola Brochette
$70.00+
Mini Meatballs
$40.00+
Swedish Meatballs
$40.00+
Coconut Chicken
$45.00+
Sweet and Sour Meatballs
$40.00+
Buffalo Shrimp
$70.00+
Desserts
list
Cake
All cakes include two fillings with icing, cake plates, forks, napkins (one setting per person)
$20.00+
Assorted Mini Pastries
$15.00
Assorted Cookies
$12.00
Fudge Brownie
$1.40
Peanut Butter Brownie
$1.40
Cream Cheese Brownie
$1.40
Rocky Road Brownie
$1.40
Peanut Butter Mousse Cake
10 inch
$36.50
White Chocolate Mousse Cake
10 inch
$36.50
Charlotte Cecilia Mousse Cake
10 inch
$36.50
Tri-Color Mousse Cake
10 inch
$36.50
Tiramisu
10 inch
$36.50
Orange Cream Mousse Cake
10 inch
$36.50
Cappucino Mousse Cake
10 inch
$36.50
Black Forest Whipcream Cake
10 inch
$33.00
Cannoli Whipcream Cake
10 inch
$33.00
Truffle Whipcream Cake
10 inch
$33.00
Victory Whipcream Cake
10 inch
$33.00
Strawberry Shortcake
10 inch
$33.00
Brown Derby Whipcream Cake
10 inch
$33.00
Maryanne Whipcream Cake
10 inch
$33.00
Plain Cheesecake
10 inch
$28.00
Marble Cheesecake
10 inch
$28.00
Chocolate Cheesecake
10 inch
$30.00
New York Style with Fresh Strawberries Cheesecake
10 inch
$37.00
Banana Cream Pie
10 inch
$21.00
Key Lime Pie
8 inch. Only available Easter through summer.
$21.00
Tropical Fruit Torte
Rectangular
$25.50
Chocolate Cream Pie
10 inch
$21.00
Specialty Desserts
list
Lemon Raspberry
Vanilla cake filled with lemon and raspberry preserves and iced with lemon butter cream.
$24.25
Fudge Double Chocolate
Chocolate cake filled with rich chocolate fudge and iced with the same fudge.
$24.25
Raspberry Torte
Vanilla cake layered and topped with raspberry preserves; the sides iced with vanilla butter cream and mixed nuts.
$24.25
Tiramisu
Vanilla cake soaked in Espresso coffee, then filled and iced with cappuccino butter cream and topped with cocoa powder
$24.25
Napoleon Cake
Vanilla cake filled with vanilla custard and finished off with Napoleon pastry shavings and powdered sugar.
$24.25
Black Forest
Chocolate cake soaked in cherry liqueur and filled with black cherry filling. The cake is iced with whipped cream and topped with a Maraschino cherry. The sides are covered in chocolate shavings.
$24.25
Strawberry Shortcake
Vanilla cake filled with a mixture of strawberries and whipped cream and iced with whipped cream.
$24.25
Carrot Cake
Carrot cake filled with iced and cream cheese. The sides are covered with chopped walnuts. and secret Hawaiian spices
$24.25
Lemon Coconut
Vanilla cake with lemon filling and iced with vanilla butter cream, then topped with coconut shavings.
$24.25
Blackout Cake
Chocolate cake filled with bittersweet chocolate pudding, topped with more chocolate and chocolate chips.
$24.25
New York Cheesecake
A gourmet’s choice. The taste and texture are creamy, rich, smooth, and unforgettable. This dessert is balanced to perfection.
$32.25
Midnight in Venice
Three layers of vanilla and chocolate cake with two layers of cannoli filling. This fantastic creation is covered with mountains of bittersweet chocolate and pignoli and sliced almonds.
$36.75
Frutta Di Bosco
Fragrant puff pastry decorated with a rich assortment of blackberries, raspberries, blueberries, and currants; filled with a delicious chantilly cream.
$34.75
Vesuvius
Dark chocolate brownie cake with a layer of caramel and fluffy cheesecake on top. The base is then dipped in chocolate ganache and surrounded by toasted nuts. This creation erupts with a mound of chocolate mousse on top and dark chocolate truffle bombs around the entire edge. This natural disaster is finished off with caramel, chocolate, and chocolate drizzle with more nuts and a few chocolate chips for good measure.
$41.25
Banana-Ramalicious
Four layers of moist banana cake filled with three layers of banana ganache. This cake is then dipped in white banana ganache and simply decorated with chocolate drizzle on top.
$37.25
Fudge Gourmet Brownie
$32.25
Cookies and Cream Gourmet Brownie
$33.25
Rocky Road Gourmet Brownie
$37.75
Cream Cheese Gourmet Brownie
$37.75
Blondies Gourmet Brownie
$33.25
Packaged Cookies
Mix of Peanut Butter, Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, and Chocolate Chocolate Chip
$0.75
Menu Categories
close
Ala Carte Specials - Sandwich Platters
Ala Carte Specials - Submarine Sandwiches
Ala Carte Specials - Individual Platters
Ala Carte Specials - Fresh Cold Salads
Ala Carte Specials - Fresh Fruits
Specialty Salads (New!)
Stuffed Breads
Specialty Sandwiches
Individual Hot Trays - Pasta
Individual Hot Trays - Rice And Beans
Individual Hot Trays - Potatoes
Individual Hot Trays - Vegetables
Individual Hot Trays - Poultry
Individual Hot Trays - Beef
Individual Hot Trays - Pork
Individual Hot Trays - Seafood
Individual Hot Trays - Veal
Individual Hot Trays - Hors D'oeuvers
Desserts
Specialty Desserts
Buy with
Back to Menu
close
You already have an order at
Custodi Caterers
error
This restaurant is not accepting online orders
×
Cannot be used with coupons!
error
error
Special Instructions
Quantity
remove
add
When would you like your order?
ASAP
Later
ASAP
Future orders not allowed
Online Ordering is not available now!
Your Addresses
Street Address *
Street Address is required
Apt/Unit/Suite
City *
City is required
State is required
Zipcode is required
Apply Coupon
Please Select One (1 Coupon Per Order)
Promo Code
Promo Code is required
Sign in
close
Continue with Google
Continue with Apple
Continue with Facebook
Continue as Guest
or use your Email and Password
Email
Email is required
Invalid Email
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy
and
Terms of Service
apply.
Password
Password is required
Forgot password?
Create Account w/ Email
By continuing, you agree to the
Terms of Use and Privacy Policy
.
Verification Required
Check your inbox
close
Code
Code is required
Choose Payment Method
close
close
Sorry, this restaurant is no longer accepting orders...
close
error
Online ordering is closed now
Find nearby restaurants
Submit Feedback
Feedback Type *
I found a bug
I have a suggestion
Other feedback
Your Email *
Your Email is required
Invalid Email
Message *
Message is required
Thank you for your feedback!
Your web browser is no longer supported
Please upgrade to a modern, fully supported browser to use Beyond Menu.
Try the latest versions of our supported browsers below.
Google Chrome
Firefox